Tarrytown The Musical

Step into Tarrytown — Adam Wachter’s hauntingly beautiful new musical that reimagines Washington Irving’s timeless legend with a contemporary, heart-stirring score.

For one night only, Broadway and television favorites Krysta Rodriguez (The Addams Family, First Date, Smash) and Andy Mientus (Les Miserables, Spring Awakening, The Flash) illuminate the historic stage of the Tarrytown Music Hall — just steps from where the legend was first told.

With romance, wit, and music that blends Broadway brilliance with folk-inspired melodies, Tarrytown is more than a ghost story — it’s a tale of love, longing, and the ties that echo across time.

An exclusive, star-studded event in Sleepy Hollow’s own backyard. Reserve your seat today.

Andy Mientus (Performer)

Andy Mientus is best known to television audiences for his role as Kyle Bishop on NBC’s Smash, as well as memorable appearances on The Flash, The Sandman (Netflix), and Dolly Parton’s Heartstrings (Netflix). On Broadway, Andy starred as Marius in the 2014 revival of Les Misérables and appeared in Spring Awakening with Deaf West Theatre. His additional stage credits include Carrie (MCC Theater), Wicked, and regional premieres across the country. Also an accomplished writer, Andy is the author of the Backstagers series from BOOM! Studios and the YA novel Fraternity. He continues to balance work as a performer and creator across stage, screen, and page.

Krysta Rodriguez (Performer)

Krysta Rodriguez has appeared in ten Broadway productions, most recently starring as Cinderella in the hit revival of Into the Woods. She originated roles in The Addams Family (Wednesday Addams), First Date, and Good Vibrations, and starred in the critically acclaimed Deaf West production of Spring Awakening. On television, Krysta is best known for her role as Ana Vargas in NBC’s Smash, as well as appearances in Daybreak (Netflix), Trial & Error (NBC), Quantico (ABC), and Halston (Netflix) where she portrayed Liza Minnelli. A versatile artist and educator, Krysta is also the co-founder of the digital platform Broadway Unlocked and continues to develop new work across stage and screen.